Podcast ratings and what they tell us

At Fresh Air, we’re huge fans of Dan Misener at ‘Bumper’. Since his time at Pacific Content he’s established himself as one of the world’s leaders in podcast insights. Fair do’s to the fella, because he’s recently spent time analysing over 28 million Apple Podcast Star ratings . The long nights must have flown by.

But what does all this analysis tell us? Well, in short, only 28% of podcasts have any ratings at all, and 87% of ratings are 5 stars. Explicit shows (i.e. with a bit of sweariness in them) get more highly rated than clean ones, and true crime podcasts get the most stars by a mile.

It’s important to remember that we know for a fact Apple star ratings make very little difference to your ranking in the podcast charts or the recommendation algorithms. So perhaps reviews are a pure vanity metric, most often posted by friends of the podcaster to make them look good. So don’t stress if no-one is reviewing your podcast, but if you want to see those stars go up, making some sweary crime is the secret. Thanks for all the work Dan.


Related News

  • Untitled post 1516

    EDITORIAL

    On Tuesday, I stayed in a Premier Inn and only had cereal for breakfast. This has never happened before. You know as well as I do that a Premier Inn breakfast consists of Coco Pops followed by toast, pancakes and a full English with some fruit and yoghurt to finish. But I’m trying to introduce…

  • Loving your listeners and profitability for Acast

    EDITORIAL

    Loving your listeners and profitability for Acast

    I love you. I’ve never found the right time or way to say it before, but a podcast-related newsletter on Valentine’s Day feels perfect. Don’t worry, you don’t have to say it back straight away. I understand it might have come as a bit of a shock and you’ll need time to process things. Please…

  • Podcasts at Work and at Sea

    EDITORIAL

    Podcasts at Work and at Sea

    We all know that the idea of Blue Monday is a load of rubbish invented by a holiday company, so I hereby declare today to be Orange Friday. We’ve been going at it now for three weeks of 2025 and so we’re really into the swing of things. We’re feeling energised, up-and-at-‘em, excited about the…